Can I Refreeze Cheesecake?

Hemera Technologies/ Images

Cheesecake is a rich, sweet dessert that shouldn't go to waste, which is why freezing leftover cheesecake is a good idea if you plan to store it for longer than a week. Fortunately, if you have properly defrosted your cheesecake in the refrigerator, you can usually safely refreeze it without having to worry about spoilage. However, continual freezing and thawing may negatively affect your cheesecake's texture and taste.

Chilling Out Cheesecake

Because cheesecake is made with dairy products, including cream cheese as the main ingredient, you must refrigerate it at 40 degrees Fahrenheit or below to prevent the growth of harmful mold and bacteria. Refrigerated cheesecake has a shelf life of about one week, but if you put it in the freezer, it can last for around six to eight months at 0 F, according to the EatByDate website. If your cheesecake has been consistently refrigerated for less than seven days, you can safely freeze it, even if it had previously been frozen. Discard cheesecake that's been left out at room temperature for more than two hours.

Don't Freeze Spoiled Cheesecake

While freezing greatly slows the growth of most harmful spoilage microorganisms, it doesn't kill them if they've already begun to develop. What this means is that if your cheesecake is showing visible signs of mold growth, developed a sour smell or has started to change in color or texture, freezing won't make it edible. Generally, if your cheesecake has been refrigerated for a total of seven days, including all days between each freezing, it's time to toss it. If it is good, wrap it up in plastic or aluminum foil to prevent the freezer from drying out the cake or from the cake picking up any unpleasant odors.

The Cycle of Freezing and Thawing

If your cheesecake is still good and you refreeze it, ice crystals will form within it because it contains moisture. Once you thaw the cheesecake in the refrigerator, these ice crystals will melt and may cause the cake to become a bit soggy in some parts, like the crust of the cake, and dry in others. This melting process could also change the texture of the cake to a gritty and unpleasant one, rather than one that is smooth and creamy. While these unpleasant effects may occur slightly after refreezing the cake once, the ice crystals that form will become larger in each successive refreeze, thus negatively affecting the cake more each time, warns Food Product Design.

Wrap It Individually

Cut your cheesecake into individual slices just after you bake it or after you thaw a store-bought frozen cheesecake. Wrap each individual slice in plastic or aluminum foil and freeze them. This way, you can thaw only the pieces you are going to eat within a few days in the refrigerator rather than freezing, thawing and then refreezing your entire cheesecake each time you want to eat it. Don't freeze any toppings or whipped cream on top of the cheesecake; instead keep these items refrigerated and add them to the thawed slices as needed. Always thaw your cheesecake slices in the refrigerator overnight or for less than two hours at room temperature to avoid spoilage.