Cinnamon and allspice are both seasonings that tend to be used in sweet dishes such as cakes and cookies. Their flavors are dissimilar, although they go well together in many recipes. Cinnamon has a mellower flavor, while allspice has a stronger flavor that sometimes overpowers other ingredients. Because of its stronger flavor, it is not a good to substitute allspice for cinnamon in recipes without adjusting quantities and flavors. It is less risky to use cinnamon instead of allspice, because the mellower flavor is less likely to stand out and call attention to itself.
The Appeal of Allspice
Unlike cinnamon, nutmeg and cloves, which were originally grown in Asia, allspice is a New World plant. When fifteenth-century European explorers sailed west in search of spices from the East, they did not find the spices that were commanding high prices in Europe, but they did find allspice, which can be used in similar types of recipes. Although the flavor of allspice is similar to that of cloves, it is a bit sweeter and not quite as sharp tasting.
The Appeal of Cinnamon
Cinnamon has been used in both sweet and savory dishes since pre-Roman times, when caravans imported the spice from the Near and Far East. Cinnamon is used in Indian curries and Greek pasta dishes, as well as sugar cookies and sticky cinnamon buns. Its flavor blends well with other seasonings and also stands on its own with a rich, distinctive bite. Like the grapes used to make fine wines, cinnamon has vintages and flavors characteristic of different regions such as Ceylon and Madagascar.
Substituting Cinnamon for Allspice
If a recipe calls for allspice but you only have cinnamon on hand, this substitution will change the flavor of the dish but the cinnamon is unlikely to overpower other flavors that can hold up to the strong taste of allspice. Adding cloves and even a bit of nutmeg can bring back some of the sharpness that allspice has that cinnamon lacks. Some savory Caribbean dishes use allspice in combination with thyme, creating a flavor synergy that is unlike either of its elements. Using cinnamon in place of allspice in these dishes would not create a similar taste.
Substituting Allspice for Cinnamon
If a recipe calls for cinnamon but you only have allspice on hand, you may be better off leaving out the spice altogether. If you do want the flavor of a sweet spice in your sweet or savory dish, start with about a third of the amount that the recipe lists rather than making a direct substitution. Taste the dish in progress, and add more allspice if the flavor isn't too strong.
Can I Use Cumin Seeds Instead of Ground ...
Can Cinnamon Lose Its Potency?
About Fresh Ginger Substitutes
Wines to Serve With Cajun or Creole Food
Galangal Powder Substitute
Tanqueray Gin Ingredients
Baking Substitution for Rosewater
Difference Between Clover & Orange ...
Garam Masala Substitute
Substitutes for Ground Cinnamon
How to Substitute for Molasses in Baking
Substitute for English Mustard
What Can You Use to Substitute ...
Can I Substitute Ground Cinnamon for ...
Nigerian Herbs & Spices
Classic Russian Spices
How to Cook a Whole Fish Jamaican Style
Substitute for Sorghum in Gingerbread
Substitutes For Tequila
Devra Gartenstein is a self-taught professional cook who has authored two cookbooks: "The Accidental Vegan", and "Local Bounty: Seasonal Vegan Recipes". She founded Patty Pan Cooperative, Seattle's oldest farmers market concession, and teaches regular cooking classes.
Dynamic Graphics/Creatas/Getty Images