Look for sweeteners with a comparable consistency to sorghum, preferably ones made from similar processes. Molasses is a good one-for-one substitute for sorghum in gingerbread cookies or cakes, but you will need to adjust the overall amount of sugar in the recipe. Sorghum is sweeter than molasses, so increase any other sugars in the recipe by up to one-third. If no other sugars are called for in the recipe you are using, simply increase the molasses slightly. Work with small batches until you get the combination that appeals to you.

Honey is another viable alternative, but the National Sweet Sorghum Producers and Processors Association recommends avoiding honey and sorghum substitutions in cookies and cakes if the recipe includes baking powder. Choose a recipe that uses baking soda instead, as the soda is needed to neutralize the acidity in honey when used in baked goods.