Can You Substitute Quick Cook Oats for Rolled Oats in Baking?

Medioimages/Photodisc/Photodisc/Getty Images

Quick cooking oats and rolled oats have distinct differences, but you may substitute one for the other in most baked goods. Quick cooking oats have been processed more than rolled oats, making them slightly softer and more able to absorb liquid. Although the quick version offers slightly less fiber than rolled oats, all other nutrients remain the same. In the end, both types impart a chewy, slightly nutty flavor to your favorite baked treats.

Roll, Roll, Roll Your Oat

Oats come from a plant that grows plentifully in the United States and other countries that get ample rainfall. The unprocessed groat looks like a grain of rice. Steel cut oats—also called Irish or Scottish oats—are minimally processed by cutting the grain once to allow water to penetrate. Rolled oats are mashed under huge rollers to flatten the grain, then steamed and toasted for a softer and faster-cooking product. Quick-cooking oats are rolled and steamed again to flatten them and shorten the cooking time even further.

Cutting the Cooking Time

The biggest difference between steel-cut, rolled and quick-cooking oats is the amount of time it takes to soften the grain to make it palatable. Steel-cut oats rarely get as soft and mushy as quick-cooking oats, but they become chewy after boiling for about 20 minutes. Rolled oats cook in about half the time, and quick-cooking oats cook in one to two minutes.

Mix Up the Texture

In recipes that call for oats, rolled oats provide a chewy, nutty texture and flavor, while quick-cooking oats supply a softer, moister finished product. Both can be used interchangeably in many recipes, and you may even substitute oats for up to one-third of the flour in most baked goods. Use steel cut oats if you want a baked good with a crunchy, nut-like texture. Avoid prepackaged instant oatmeal as it often contains added sugar and flavorings, and the finer texture absorbs too much liquid from the batter.

Pat Yourself on the Back

When you cook with oats, you increase the amount of beneficial fiber and other nutrients in baked goods. All forms of oats contain a soluble fiber called beta glucan that helps lower cholesterol. Additionally, oats are fat- and gluten-free, and they are an excellent source of magnesium, phosphorus and potassium.