Difference Between White Cheddar & Yellow Cheddar

Image by Flickr.com, courtesy of Chris Buecheler

The word cheddar can traditionally bring to mind a thick slice of bright orange cheese. However, white cheddar is now claiming shelf space at grocery stores as well. Except for the color, there is actually very little difference between white and yellow or orange cheddar cheeses.


Cheddar cheese is a harder cheese that can range from mild to very sharp in flavor. Whether yellow or white, the cheese must be aged to achieve its distinctive flavor; the longer the aging process, the sharper the cheddar.


The main difference between white and yellow cheddar is usually a simple food coloring, which was originally added to distinguish where the cheddar was made. Cheddar cheeses made in the New England states, for example, traditionally do not contain color additives and, thus, retain their natural white coloring while Wisconsin cheddar cheese is often colored with annatto, a natural food coloring, to give it its trademark yellow image.


Cheddar cheese, whether white or yellow, is made from cow's milk. After the milk is curdled, the whey is drained and the curds are piled up, forming the base of the cheese. The bright yellow or orange cheddars on display at grocery stores owe their coloring to food dyes and color additives, such as annatto.


Many people claim to taste a difference between white and yellow cheddar cheese. In fact, all yellow cheddar is actually white cheddar with coloring. The additives do not contribute to the taste. Cheddar cheeses differ in taste based on sharpness due to aging. It is also worth taking into consideration whether the cheese has been heavily processed or is natural, and what region it comes from. For example, according to "Cheese Guru" Andy Shay, cheddars made in Ontario, Canada, tend to be pasteurized and have a sharp, pleasant bite while Quebec cheddars are often made from raw milk and are lightly fruity in flavor.

Fun Facts

Cheddar cheese originated in a village called Cheddar, located in Somerset County, England. The village is also known for producing a large amount of strawberries.

Aged cheddar cheeses contain 0 grams of lactose.