Does Canola Oil Taste the Same as Vegetable Oil When Baking?

Noel Hendrickson/Digital Vision/Getty Images

You might wonder if you can substitute canola oil for vegetable oil. Learn when it's okay to bake with oil and when you can switch between the two.

Taste Test

Canola oil has a neutral, pleasant flavor that is rarely discernible in baked goods. Vegetable oil has a similarly light, mild taste that you probably won't notice either. The type of vegetable oil you use can make a difference. Corn oil has a darker color and richer flavor than other types of vegetable oil. Olive oil -- classified as a vegetable oil -- adds a nutty sweetness to baked goods, especially if you use a virgin or extra virgin type. In most cases, though, you won't notice any difference between canola oil and other types of vegetable oils. Discard any vegetable or canola oil that has a sharp, bitter odor or flavor, which indicates the oil is rancid.

The Refinery

Regardless of which oil you use, choose a refined one. Refining makes oils more stable and also gives them a neutral flavor -- ideal components for baking. Refined oils usually cost less than natural, unrefined oils, which makes sense when you're choosing an oil for baking.

Baking With Oil

Vegetable oil and canola oil work best in dense, moist cakes and quick breads. They don't perform as well in cookies or light cakes because you can't cream them with sugar. Creaming creates tiny pockets of air in the batter. During baking, these pockets fill with steam, lightening and lifting the baked good. The result is fluffy, tender cakes with a fine crumb, and cookies that are crisp on the outside and chewy on the inside. Cookies, in particular, are flat, moist and soft when made with vegetable or canola oil.

Switch It Up

Use vegetable oil or canola oil interchangeably in any recipe that calls for oil. If you use them in a recipe that calls for a solid fat, such as butter, replace each 1/4 cup of butter or shortening with 3 tablespoons of oil. Avoid using virgin and extra-virgin olive oils in baking unless you want a pronounced olive flavor. Stick with regular olive oil instead.