Being more holistic in your diet may be good for you. Raw or minimally cooked fruits and vegetables, unprocessed flour and other natural foods have been proven to have some health benefits or at least not harmful benefits. Goat milk is touted as less allergenic and flavorful. However, when it comes to goat milk, the level of "natural" may make it an unhealthy choice.
There were 335,000 milk goats listed in the U.S. in January 2009. That is a 4 percent increase over the previous year. The main dairy goat breeds in the U.S. are Alpine, LaMancha, Nubian, Oberhasli, Saanen and Toggenburg. Goat milk production and uses are increasing.
FDA on Raw Milk
The FDA regulation that all milk and milk products meant for direct human consumption must be pasteurized was published on August 10, 1987. It states that unpasteurized milk may be dangerous no matter how carefully prepared due to dangers of bacteria, pathogens, infectious organisms, gastrointestinal disease, diseases shed through the cow's udders and animal to human (zoonotic) disease transmission. The American Academy of Pediatrics, other federal and state health agencies and the Centers for Disease Control agreed. This includes certified raw milk. The American Veterinarian Association also agrees that milk should be pasteurized as animals can appear healthy, but still be shedding diseases we lack the ability to test for.
Legalities of Raw
Most states make the selling of raw milk illegal. As of 2009, Pennsylvania and a few other states do permit sales to consumers by certified farms, but most state certification testing is no more stringent than for farms that produce pasteurized milk. Georgia allows sale of raw milk, but the seller must mark it as not for human consumption. Raw milk used for making cheese is not included in the ban in many states.
Raw Milk Related Disease
Some of the most common outbreaks linked directly to unpasteurized milk are Salmonella, Campylobacter, Listeriousis, Yersinia enterocolitica infections, Escherichia coli, Coxiella Burnetti (Q-Fever) and Chlamydia. Although it is not proven that rabies can be transmitted, because there is no proof it cannot be, it is also on the list of possible dangers of raw milk.
Safe Raw Uses
The FDA and CDC concludes that pasteurization is the only way to reliably reduce the dangers of milk. Research has not proven there are any nutritional value differences between pasteurized and unpasteurized milk. However, some recipes for making cheese require raw milk. These cheeses must be aged at least 60 days before selling sale in the U.S. However, certified raw cheese can be exported since 2007. Raw goat milk is also used to make soaps.
Pasteurized Goat Milk
Pasteurized goat milk is as safe as cow milk, and you can use pasteurized goat milk every way regular cow milk is used. It is not recommended for use in infants under six months of age without doctor approval, however.
Raw Goat Milk
USDA/ARS Children's Nutrition Research Center at Baylor College of Medicine in Houston says while there are documented risk of raw milk, there are no proven benefits. Unpasteurized milk can be particularly dangerous for anyone with immune issues, children, pregnant women and the elderly. The Mayo Clinic agrees, stating that raw milk and even raw milk cheeses are not safe to drink, eat or use in cooking.
- Carol Thacker/iStock/Getty Images