Adding Half-and-Half to Thicken Soups

close-up of a hand stirring a bowl of soup cooking on a stove

Stockbyte/Stockbyte/Getty Images

Once the weather turns chilly and you’ve gotten your sweaters out of storage, nothing seems as warming as a steaming bowl of thick, creamy soup. Adding half-and-half or cream is a delicious way to give soups extra body and a smooth texture. From a health perspective, half-and-half is a better choice than you might think.

Best Thickening Choice

There is a confusing array of milk products in the dairy case. What’s the difference between half-and-half, light cream, heavy cream and whipping cream – and which one is best for thickening soup? What differentiates one cream from the next is fat content. Half-and-half, a mixture of half milk and half cream, has a fat content of about 12 percent, vs. about 20 percent for light cream, and 35 to 40 percent for heavy whipping cream. The higher the fat content, the thicker the cream will be. You can use any of these creams to thicken a soup, but half-and-half is thick enough to give cream soups a rich consistency -- without as much fat as the others.

What About Fat?

Health-conscious eaters may still worry about adding dairy fat to foods. Contrary to popular belief, a 2010 study in the Annals of Internal Medicine showed that the kind of fats found in dairy products actually reduce the risk of Type 2 diabetes and heart disease. The small amount of half-and-half used to thicken a soup -- maybe ½ to 1 cup -- isn’t significant enough to cause concern about fat content. Regular, light or skim milks don’t have enough fat to thicken soups alone anyway, and have a tendency to separate or curdle when heated.

Fat-Free Half-and-Half?

You may wonder about a product in stores called “fat free half-and-half.” In this highly processed product, the natural butterfat has been replaced with corn syrup, chemicals and thickeners to simulate the mouth feel and texture of fat. Most nutrition experts agree that it is a much healthier choice to eat the natural saturated or monounsaturated fats in half-and-half than the chemicals, sugars and processed grains in the fat-free version.

No-Fat Option

If you are really concerned about calories – or want to skip dairy altogether – give your soup extra body with the help of your blender. Puree just 1 or 2 cups of the soup in a blender and returning the puree back to the soup pot.