Pulled pork is a favorite at barbecues and parties. Whether you like it slathered with barbecue sauce or simply smoked, it’s delightful when piled high on your favorite sandwich roll. Unfortunately, ordering a tray of pre-pulled pork can be prohibitively expensive. Luckily, pulling it yourself is incredibly easy, and much less expensive than ordering catering for your next family gathering.
Heat pork butt (also called pork shoulder) to between 180 and 190 degrees Fahrenheit. Use a meat thermometer at the thickest point of the butt to determine its true temperature.
Allow meat to cool to a touchable temperature. You can begin pulling it as soon as you can stand to touch it, which will depend on your sensitivity to heat. Latex, nitrile, or nyplex gloves may enable you to pull the pork when it’s hotter than you’d be able to stand with bare hands.
Pull the pork, working with the grain of the meat. Separate any large chunks of fat or cartilage and discard them in the garbage can.
Place pulled pork in the roasting pan as you pull it. That way, when you’re done, you can easily cover it with aluminum foil for reheating or storage.
Pour chicken broth or apple juice over the pan of pork once you’ve finished pulling it. This will keep it from drying out when you reheat it.
Heat pork through before serving, whether you serve immediately after pulling or store it for a few days before serving.
Nitrile and nyplex gloves are good alternatives if you have a latex allergy. Check your local hardware store to find these types of gloves.
If you will not be serving the pork immediately after you’ve pulled it, store it in the refrigerator as soon as it has reached room temperature. For optimum food safety consideration, reheat to 160 degrees Fahrenheit in order to kill any and all possible bacterial contaminants.
Do not allow pork butt to cool too much before attempting to pull it. As the meat cools, the fat and connective tissue will start to congeal, making pulling much more difficult. This is why using gloves is recommended, so that you can start pulling while the meat is hotter.
Although it has been smoked, pork butt should not be allowed to sit at room temperature for an excessive period of time. Pork at 180-190 degrees Fahrenheit should not sit out for consumption for periods in excess of 4 hours. If the pork has not been refrigerated after 2 hours, it must be consumed before 4 hours have elapsed, or else should be thrown away.