Lean and gamey, venison needs an extra kick of flavor and a cooking technique that doesn't put a squeeze on its already minimal juiciness. Brining and smoking have it covered. An overnight brine fills the venison with some much-needed extra moisture, and smoking adds just enough cover to hide any traces of gaminess without sacrificing the taste of the meat. The deer venison shoulder corresponds with beef chuck, so you smoke it the same way, but you have to remove it from the heat as soon as it's safe to eat so it doesn't get unnecessarily tough.
Create a basic meat brine with a ratio of two quarts water to 1/2 cup each kosher salt and granulated sugar. Make enough to submerge the venison shoulder. Bring to a boil in a pot or saucepan and stir.
Stir the brine until the sugar and salt dissolve, then turn the heat off. Add any aromatic ingredients, whole spices or herbs to the brine and let them steep as it cools to room temperature.
Pour the brine in a stainless-steel pot or food-storage container large enough to contain the deer shoulder and the brine. Chill the brine in the refrigerator until it reaches 40 degrees Fahrenheit or below.
Remove the deer shoulder from the refrigerator and trim off as much fat and connective tissue as you can. If you have thin bands of silverskin attached, slice through them with a kitchen knife to score them, but don't cut into the meat.
Place the deer shoulder in the brine and cover. Brine the shoulder in the refrigerator for 24 hours.
Soak about one pound of hardwood chips in water for two hours before you start the grill.
Remove the deer shoulder from the brine and rinse. The excess sugar will burn and the salt will concentrate during smoking.
Pat the shoulder dry with paper towels. Coat the shoulder with salt and pepper or spice rub or spice paste of your choice.
Set up your grill for smoking. If you have a charcoal grill, place one or two aluminum drip pans, depending on the size, half-filled with water on one side of the charcoal tray. Light a chimney starter full of lump charcoal and dump it on the side of the charcoal tray opposite the water trays after it ashes over. Cover the charcoal with a layer of wood chips. Close the grill lid and let it heat. If you have a gas grill, place one or two aluminum drip pans half full of water on one side of the burners. Place a woodchip smoker box filled with woodchips on the burners on the side opposite the water trays. Set the heat to medium-high and close the lid.
Place the deer shoulder on the side of the grill you placed the water pans on. Close the all the grill vents and the lid. Check the grill's thermostat after about 30 minutes. If the temperature is above 300 degrees Fahrenheit, open the vent on the bottom of the grill about halfway. If the temperature reads below 250 F, add more coals. Adjust the temperature as needed on gas grills so it stays between 250 and 300 F.
Smoke the deer shoulder for about 1.5 hours per pound, or until it reaches an internal temperature of 140 F. The temperature will raise to the minimum required temperature for safe eating of 145 F during the rest period.
Replenish the woodchips about every 20 to 30 minutes. Check the water every hour during smoking, adding enough water as needed so they don't dry out.
Remove the deer shoulder from the grill and let it rest for 20 minutes per pound before cutting into it.
Items you will need
- Boneless deer shoulder
- Kosher salt
- Pot or saucepan
- Aromatic ingredients, whole spices and herbs
- Stainless-steel pot or food-storage container
- Kitchen knife
- Hardwood chips
- Paper towels
- Spice rub or spice paste (optional)
- Aluminum drip pans
- Meat thermometer
- Hemera Technologies/PhotoObjects.net/Getty Images